Could Legalizing Marijuana Help Balance the Budget?

There is a growing consensus here in the United States that we need to get our budget in order, and soon.  The deficit is rising higher and higher, the national debt is steadily building, and there’s not much agreement on what to do.  Rather, there’s not much political will to do what most people readily agree should be done: some combination of cutting public spending and raising taxes that will be painful in the short term (to say nothing of harmful to some politicians’ careers) but ultimately in the best interest of the country as a whole.

But what if there were a tax that, if put into place, would be gladly paid by those being taxed, could conceivably generate large profits, and would decrease government spending?  Impossible, you say?  The ravings of a deranged madman intent on world domination, you claim?

Part of my plan to dominate the world using giant hamsters
Part of my plan to dominate the world using giant hamsters

Perhaps.  But those are some of the claims being made about legalizing marijuana for recreational use.  The argument goes like this: in spite of the US government’s best efforts, marijuana use has been fairly widely used, even back to when it was first outlawed in the 1930’s.  Much like Prohibition of alcohol during the 1920’s (which, interestingly enough, was repealed at about the time marijuana was outlawed), the laws against marijuana use have only criminalized a personal act that harms nobody but the user, made criminals out of otherwise law-abiding citizens, and allowed the criminal element to make use of marijuana sales as a source of illicit funds.  By legalizing marijuana, we can not only eliminate these issues but also generate a rather sizable new source of income for the government, to boot.

So, the question, as posed in an oddly phrased way in the inspiration for this blog entry, becomes ‘Is it worth legalizing and taxing marijuana as a method of reducing the debt?’

The Economics of Legalization

If we focus on the economics of legalization as opposed to other issues like morals, ethics, and possible addictions, it seems like it should be pretty easy to figure out how much income the government could derive from legalization.  Alas, the illicit nature of marijuana currently makes it difficult to get accurate numbers; the Justice Department itself notes that it’s nigh impossible to get accurate estimates of how much marijuana is sold in the US due to the clandestine nature of the business.

There are various ways to make reasonable guesses at the total amount of marijuana both grown and imported; if we extrapolate from amount of marijuana seized yearly (around 1100 metric tons) and assume that represents about 10% of the marijuana in the US, we can estimate about 11,000 metric tons of marijuana imported or produced domestically in the US each year.  (That’s 11.0 billion grams of marijuana, a figure that we’ll need in just a minute.)

That’s all well and good (and a sign of just how popular marijuana use has become), but the real question is how much revenue could be derived.  This is another tricky one; we can’t tell for certain how much the use of marijuana will change if legalized.  We might see a huge increase, the levels could stay steady, or use might even decrease (perhaps it won’t be ‘cool’ anymore).  A 2005 report by Jeffrey Miron of the Harvard School of Economics suggests that the government could generate tax revenue between $2.4 billion (if marijuana was taxed at rates comparable to most normal goods) to $6.7 billion (if taxed at similar rates to alcohol and tobacco).

A much more optimistic estimate suggests using the entire premium currently commanded by drug dealers (the amount above the actual cost of production and distribution) as the tax rate, a nearly 400% rate of return for the government.  This tax rate would be around $7 per half gram of marijuana, yielding a potential total tax revenue of $154 billion on the 11 billion grams of marijuana we estimated being sold in the US.  (Assuming that (a) our assumptions about the amount of marijuana sold in the US currently are accurate, (b) that there is negligible effects on the amount of marijuana sold after legalization and taxation, and (c) that we can impose and collect taxes at that high of a level.)

But wait, that’s not all; there are also costs associated with keeping nonviolent marijuana users incarcerated and spending money for police and other services to capture them in the first place.  Again, it’s hard to say for certain how much these costs would change if marijuana was legalized (would these resources no longer be needed at all, or simply end up shifted to other uses, fighting different drugs, for instance), but our friend Miron claims that we could save $7.7 billion on enforcement costs ($2.4 billion at the national level, $5.3 billion at the state and local levels).

As To Balancing the Budget…

We now know how much we can expect to generate by legalizing and taxing marijuana , around $13 billion total (from Miron’s highest figures; about $5 billion if we use his low figures and just look at the federal government income) or as much as $154 billion (with a much more aggressive tax); is that enough to cover the budget deficit?  Not even close.  The US budget deficit for 2010 was 1.17 trillion (that’s Trillion with a T-R); even if the $154 billion figure is accurate (and it seems quite high from where I sit, especially compared with our other estimate), it won’t even be enough to get the deficit under $1 trillion, let alone provide a silver bullet to balance the budget without spending cuts or other taxes.

This doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t consider legalizing marijuana; a potential boost to federal, state and local pocketbooks to the tune of $5-13 billion dollars (perhaps much, much more) is certainly a help.  There’s also plenty of non-income related reasons to seriously consider legalization (as several states have or might in the future); from providing more freedom from government intrusion in our private lives to decreasing street crime, the advantages of legalizing marijuana seem to pretty handily outweigh the disadvantages.

Disclaimer: As you can probably guess, I’m pretty steadfastly in favor of legalizing marijuana (and most drugs, for that matter), for reasons of economics, personal freedom, and minimizing government where possible.  I do not partake in any illegal drugs (or much of legal intoxicants like alcohol, for that matter), so this column is based entirely on my thoughts and feelings rather than potential personal gain if legalization becomes law.  If you are looking for a good rebuttal to the arguments for legalization, including the ones I’ve presented here, this article is a good place to start.

Should the US legalize and tax marijuana, even if it’s unlikely to be a major factor in balancing the federal budget?  Are the benefits worth the problems that could arise?  Should the potential economics of legalization be a major consideration when discussing legalization, or should money issues be trumped by health, safety and moral concerns?

Thanks for reading another article from The Amateur Financier! If you haven't already, please consider subscribing to my RSS feed. Continue to enjoy the site, and please share any articles you enjoy with your friends!

50 Responses to Could Legalizing Marijuana Help Balance the Budget?

  1. @Jeff: I did try to include the savings from ending the ‘War on Drugs’ in our calculations (the $7.7 billion figure that Miron provides). Whether that’s a total tally of all the money that would be saved by legalizing marijuana is another question.

    @boomer: True, there is tourism to consider, as well, I suppose. How much that would generate in income is another interesting question (and part of the reason it’s so hard to pin down an exact income figure).

  2. Nice Website. I’m a medical marijuana activist myself. I believe that every dispensary that opens is another blow to the failed drug war. I support your efforts.

  3. Thanks for the comments, Toalson; I’m hardly an activist, just someone who likes to explore questions like this. I will grant that my personal philosophy is that people should be allowed to do what they will, provided that they don’t harm others against said others’ will.

  4. It’s time to legalize. The war on drugs is a dismal failure. All the myths about marijuana being a gateway drug have been disproven. The billions spent chasing after little guys for possession could be so much better spent elsewhere.

    • Fair points, Legalize. At best, the War on Drugs has had minimal effect on the actual amount of drug use; at worst, it has led to everything from wasted taxpayer money to thousands of people imprisoned for nonviolent drug offenses. All good reasons to legalize marijuana (and most other recreational drugs, for that matter).

  5. Honestly, I think some people oppose to it just because of their personal biases. I mean, why would they even want a weed user arrested/detained when said user never hurt or bothered anybody else? I think wanting that is bigoted.

    Also weed being a gateway drug to more serious substances is a crazy assumption that has been disproved. THERE IS ABSOLUTELY NO REASON TO BAN THE USE OF MARIJUANA MOST ESPECIALLY FOR ITS MEDICAL PROPERTIES!!!

  6. I think that legalized marijuana would be taxed similarly to alcohol and tobacco and that the income earned by marijuana producers would be subject to standard income and sales tax. But taxes aren’t the only source of revenue that would come from legalizing weed. State and local governments also stand to save billions of dollars that they currently spend regulating marijuana use.

  7. Great post! Really wonderful information included. Thanks so much for writing on a topic many still feel to uncomfortable to discuss. There are definitely some obvious benefits to the legalization of marijuana and its great that people are starting to see the pro’s of the decriminalization of marijuana, especially for medical use!

  8. The tax benefits for marijuana are still in early stages of research but it is looking good. There seems to be a lot of benefit and it really could drive some revenues!

  9. Nice post
    I do think that legalizing marijuana will help to boost the economy.
    Legalizing with a good control is not going to harm anybody, I would be positive for everyone, you just decide if you want to consume it or not, like other legal drugs.
    Thanks for sharing!

  10. Excellent post. I appreciate this site. Stick with it! Because the admin of this web page is working, no doubt very quickly it will be well-known, due to its quality contents.This website was how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally, I’ve found something that helped me. Thanks! Order today to buy cannabis oil online from Medical marijuana online store for sale. cannabis oil

  11. why would you spend your lifetime on leaf drug that afterward might end you up with Cancer where as you have your pain killer meds,to reduce stress,obesity,and even take you to the same level can. if you are interested to know more click here
    Butterfly Medshop´s last blog post ..Hello world!

  12. Hello, are you in search of top quality medical marijuana, tinctures, edibles, cannabis oil, weed seeds, hash oil, cbd oil and legal weeds?? Legal Marijuana Store is a group of dedicated growers specialized at cultivating and selling just the best marijuana cannabis containing the CBN,CBD and THC ingredients.
    https://www.legalmedsuppliers.com/

  13. Buy Cannabis online California: order real cannabis online , buying hash oil online USA, order weed edibles online, can i order marijuana online, how to order weed, online dispensary delivery united states, online cannabis store, order edibles, marijuana candy for sale, online cannabis, buy marijuana online usa, buy legal weed online, buy pots online legit, BUY Marijuana online , where to buy Cannabis online,
    Mark Jorden´s last blog post ..buy weed online Florida

  14. The Premium Weed Online Shop Center has become the best marijuana dispensary in Los Angeles California. They are known for quality cannabis for sale as well as expert instruction and guidance in all things marijuana. We have decided to rank them number one for this very reason. Proper dosing is the key to getting the most out of any medical marijuana treatment plan. If your looking for the best cannabis in California visit their marijuana dispensary today and see why we approve of their services.
    We have added just a few of their best products and pricing below. They are best known for weed edibles but also carry dry weed strains as well. We hope you enjoy shopping for some of their latest Indica weed strains, Sativa weed strains, hybrid weed strains, cannabis edibles, and cannabis concentrates. Please note that all weed for sale is subject to change at any time and you should visit Premium Weed Online Shop Center directly for current cannabis products and marijuana pricing.

  15. Medical Weed Online Shop is one of the largest and highest rated marijuana delivery services in Village Valley California. Their customer service is second to none. After a quick age verifying procedures that you can do on their website, you can have some of California’s best marijuana on your doorstep in minutes.

  16. To Buy Vape Carts Online, If you’re in a non-legal state like myself we do not have choices like the rest of you. I understand there may be pesticides in them and THC levels are never accurate. Are these deceiving? Absolutely. But has your dealer ever shown you lab results for the bud they get? 9/10 times you don’t The vape cartridge brands that raised in popularity experienced problems with counterfeits and quality control. We explain the evolution of vape cartridge as it transformed from a wick style into the ceramic powerhouse it has become
    get the best and authentic carts at Exotic Vape Carts Shop

  17. The Mega Marijuana Shop is quickly becoming California’s favorite marijuana dispensary to buy cannabis. We have included some of their latest cannabis indica strains, Cannabis Sativa strains, hybrid strains, marijuana edibles, and marijuana concentrates. Please note that all cannabis for sale is subject to change at any time and you should Mega Marijuana Shop website for current products and marijuana pricing.

  18. We Help People Get Proper Medications
    Xanax Online Drug Store is completely committed to providing quality when it comes to your prescription medications. Our patients are searching for a trusted, online pharmacy – including a licensed Canadian pharmacy – which offers the real deal at an affordable price.
    Xanax Drugs Store, buy Oxycodone online, buy onyx online, buy Adderall online, buy Xanax online and other anxiety drugs online. Discreet and secure delivery to your address

  19. I had never heard of CBD by itself, but as my mental state gradually destabilized and my therapist kept pushing me to get on medication, I figured Google could help. Truthfully, I was searching for a black-market online site to get weed since I didn’t have a medical card in Maryland, but instead I ended up finding CBD retailer sites with tons of different brands and forms, and the rest is history.https://stevemedsstore.com
    williams´s last blog post ..WHERE TO BUY WEED ONLINE

  20. Buy Banana Kush Brisbane Strawberry Banana is an indica dominant hybrid (70% indica/30% sativa) strain created by breeders at the infamous Serious Seeds farms as potent cross between the popular Strawberry Bubblegum X Crocket’s Banana Kush strains.buy weed online Perth This dank bud boasts an average THC level ranging from 22-26% and a myriad of surprisingly well-balanced indica and sativa effects. https://420cannabisusa.com

  21. Knuckle up! When it comes to premium CO2 oil products, Brass Knuckles aren’t messing around. They are renowned for their potency and their oil cartridges, brass knuckles carts deliver top-shelf product to their customers. Purity, integrity and no-nonsense, that’s their motto.Buy Brass Knuckles online
    Brass Knuckles vape pen stays true to the cannabis concentrate connoisseurs, using tried and tested extraction techniques. The oils are then lab-tested to ensure absolute purity, before being delivered to the customer in Brass Knuckles’ own vape pens and cartridges. Buy Brass Knuckles online
    http://exoticcartsonline.com
    James´s last blog post ..Which Type of Vaporizer Best Suits You?

  22. Hello, are you in search of top Grade Buy Space Monkey Meds by Buy Runts Buy Vape Cartrideges, you need then worry no we are sellers in North America, Europe and the World,and sell out our very affordable wide collection of strains not only to regular smokers, but some of our strains are also used as medicine for the treatment of cancer,stress, chronic pain, restore appetite,anxiety
    https://buyweedtinsonline.com/

Leave a reply

CommentLuv badge